*I realize that many of the events with in this post I have already blogged about on separate occasions. I’m sure most of my readers have heard me talk about them in person as well. However, this is the complete story of my transition from the LDS church so far, and I wanted to record it all in one post.
The foolish man built his house upon the sand.
Up until I left for college, I thought I was a spiritual rock; I thought that I would always be that way. I had served as President for my Seminary and my Young Women’s classes, lived the commandments completely, went to church, mutual, and stake activities, etc. I did not realize that it was irrelevant how many presidencies I had served in. It was irrelevant that I did not date until I was sixteen. It was irrelevant that my attendance was impeccable. All of these things helped me to build a beautiful house, but the foundation was weak. Apparently I had been too caught up in appearing to be a good Mormon, and I did not develop a testimony to accompany that. A beautiful house is only a good house if it is built well.
As I left for BYU, I was confident that I would have a good experience. I’m sure the foolish man from the primary song was also confident that his house would be fine. It’s interesting to see things from the perspective of a character that I once thought was so stupid. After all, what kind of moron would build a house on sand?
And the rains came tumbling down!
One year later on my way back to Arizona for summer vacation, I realized that something had changed. I had had many problems with BYU, but they were all manageable (I guess you could call it a drizzle that exposed a leak or two in my roof). These issues certainly did not break me, but I had developed an extremely cynical side (perhaps the too-little-too-late measure of weather resistant paint?). I became more and more negative about the culture of BYU/ Provo/ Utah/ the Church, and as such, living there became tedious.
And then Proposition 8 happened (tumbling rain). Prop. 8 was HUGE on BYU campus. Everywhere I went there were “Yes on 8” fliers and students trying to “defend the family.” During this time, I was told–among many other things–that because I did not agree with the Prophet, I “have no testimony of God.” That statement caused me to reevaluate what my belief in God was. Contrary to what this person told me, I came to the conclusion that I did actually believe in God, but it was a different God than the one many of my brothers and sisters at BYU believed in. My God was a loving and merciful God, who above all, wanted his children to be happy. I know that that is what the doctrine of the Church teaches, but in my opinion, the culture of the Church has deviated so far from that.
The rains came down and the floods came up.
This led me to begin my questioning. Where else has the Church deviated from my idea of the Gospel? What other popular teachings and traditions was I uncomfortable with? Little by little, I began to find more and more things that I disagreed with or had concerns about. Inch by inch, the waters grew, and soon the flood had arrived. I had concerns about the Temple, the patriarchy of the Church, the less-than impressive civil rights record, inconsistencies in doctrine, the treatment of women, polygamy, and eventually Joseph Smith. I had never developed a testimony of Joseph Smith, and I’m afraid that was the rain drop that caused my house to fall down.
And the house on the sand went SPLAT!
Unfortunately, I was still at BYU when this happened, and that was a bit like rubbing salt in my wounds. There is absolutely no avoiding church while you’re there. You must attend church, or you’ll be kicked out. You must take a religion class or you cannot graduate. Not to mention you are surrounded by people who always want to discuss their version of gospel principles with you, but never want to hear what your “radical” take on it is. It became overwhelming, as I felt the Church was being shoved further and further down my throat. I became bitter, resentful, and completely unhappy. I realized that I needed to change my environment (take the remains of my flooded, tumbled house and move it far away from the metaphorical sand; ironically, that took me to the West Coast).
The reason why I transferred was so that I could be happy again. I did not like leading a life of bitterness and resent. Since I’ve been here, I have made a resolve to leave that all behind, and only take the good away with me. It’s been a slow process, but it’s going relatively well. I’m not going to forget the negative aspects to the Church that I was greatly hurt by, but I’m also not going to dwell on those things. I have taken away so many positive things from my experience with the LDS Church, and I am extremely grateful for all of that.
This leaves me at a “where do I go from here” point. Part of me wants to start going to the U of O Single’s Ward, as I am told it is different from the BYU/ Provo culture that I grew to despise. Although I have no intentions to become a Sacrament-taking, temple-going member, it could be interesting to attend and observe. I feel like I would be more comfortable participating in discussion here, and that my “radical” views would be met with less hostility. Another part of me wants to try out different religions and participate in discussions elsewhere. I know of a church here that is gay friendly, has a woman pastor, and serves donuts after the meeting, so I kind of want to try that out… at least for the free donut. Also, there is a Society of Friends (Quaker) congregation in Eugene that I’d like to experience a meeting with. It’s all really up in the air right now, and I don’t know where I should go. I’m not concerned though. It always takes time to rebuild a house, and this time, I plan on doing it right.